When Is a Marriage Considered Irretrievably Broken Down?

Marriage stands as one of the most profound commitments. It is a strong bond of joy, wins, and sometimes, overwhelming losses. Yet, even the strongest bonds can fray, and sometimes, a union unravels to a point where it can no longer be restored.

The point at which a marriage is considered irretrievably broken down is an interesting juncture in the journey of love and commitment. It’s a moment that raises questions about legality and the human experience—emotions, responsibilities, and the ever-elusive pursuit of happiness.

Dive in as we explore the concept of irretrievable breakdown, examining the various legal frameworks, the emotional turbulence, and the transformative journey that leads couples to divorce or separation.

Factors Indicating An Irretrievable Breakdown Of a Marriage

There are jurisdictions with the no-fault divorce law enactment. The law considers a marriage irretrievably broken if at least one spouse believes so. The marriage can dissolve without providing proof of why it is not working. 

There are other factors that make a marriage considered irretrievably broken down. These factors include: 

Separate Living Arrangements

The state law requires that the spouses have lived separately for a specified period before a no-fault divorce can be granted. The length of the separation period varies by location. Some states recognize two years of separation with the consent of divorce or five years of separation. 

Unsuccessful Reconciliation

Before the breaking down of a marriage,  there are efforts to reconcile. These efforts include counseling or mediation. The marriage is considered irretrievably broken when there is no reasonable prospect of reconciliation or when efforts at reconciliation have failed.

Unhappiness and Incompatibility

If incompatibility and both parties feel unhappy despite efforts to make things work, the marriage can be considered irretrievably broken down.  The breakdown of the relationship ultimately reflects on the quality of the marriage. 

Related: If My Wife Wants a Divorce Can I Say No?

Does Adultery Make a Marriage Irretrievably Broken Down?

Adultery can be a significant factor in the breakdown of a marriage. However,  its role in determining whether a marriage is considered irretrievably broken down varies by jurisdiction and the specific circumstances of the couple involved. 

In some cases, adultery is grounds for divorce and can be cited as the reason for the dissolution of a marriage. In such cases, proving adultery may make it easier to obtain a divorce.

In other jurisdictions, there are “no-fault” divorce laws, where a marriage can be dissolved without proving fault or specific reasons for the divorce. 

In the no-fault divorce case, adultery alone might not be sufficient to establish that a marriage is irretrievably broken down. Instead, the focus is often on factors like separation, incompatibility, or the belief by one or both spouses that the marriage is beyond repair.

The magnitude of adultery in divorce proceedings also varies within no-fault divorce jurisdictions. While adultery may not be the sole factor leading to a divorce, it can still be relevant in matters such as property division, alimony, or child custody arrangements.

Note that each divorce case is unique, and the legal outcome may depend on the specific laws of the jurisdiction and the facts and evidence presented in the case. If you are considering a divorce and adultery is a factor in your situation, consult with a family law attorney who can provide guidance based on the laws in your jurisdiction and help you understand how adultery may impact your case.

What Happens When a Marriage Is Irretrievably Broken Down?

When a marriage is irretrievably broken down, the couple decides on the way forward, depending on the law. Below are some possible outcomes for an irretrievably broken marriage: 

Legal Separation or Divorce

Divorce is a likely outcome when a marriage breaks down irretrievably. One or both spouses typically file for divorce or legal separation in the appropriate court. The procedure and paperwork required will depend on local laws and court rules. If it comes to divorce, it is essential to have a family law attorney to give legal guidance for the proceedings. 

Settling Financial Issues

Regarding separation, you must settle the division of marital assets, debts, or property. The settlement is usually through negotiation, mediation, or, if necessary, litigation. 

The court can determine asset division if the parties cannot agree on financial matters. 

Custody Settlements

It is required for a couple with children to make arrangements for child custody if they have children. Child custody discussions can be in negotiation, mediation, or court orders. The discussions also involve child support issues and the specific contribution each party should make in raising the children. 

Alimony Agreements

Sometimes, one partner may be required to support the other financially. The court determines the amount and duration of alimony. The couple can also agree on alimony based on their unique circumstances. 

Legal Process

Divorce involves procedures of the court. Legal proceedings, including court hearings and the submission of required documentation, will occur to finalize the divorce or legal separation. The complexity and duration of this process can vary depending on circumstances and whether the couple can agree on the required settlements. 

Divorce Finalization

Once all issues have been resolved, the court issues a divorce decree or judgment, officially ending the marriage. The decree outlines the divorce terms, including property division, spousal support, child custody, and visitation arrangements. 

After the divorce, the spouses have the legal and financial independence to move forward separately. In the event the divorced couple chooses to reconcile, they can remarry.


Do you need to provide reasons or faults for a divorce based on irretrievable breakdown?

In many no-fault divorce jurisdictions, you do not need to provide specific reasons or fault for the divorce. It can often be based on the assertion that the marriage has broken down.

Can couples attempt reconciliation even if a marriage is considered irretrievably broken?

Yes, couples can attempt to reconcile even if a marriage is irretrievably broken down. In some cases, reconciliation efforts can occur before or during the divorce process.

Can legal separation be an alternative to divorce when a marriage is irretrievably broken down?

Some couples choose legal separation instead of divorce when they believe their marriage is irretrievably broken down. Legal separation can address financial and custodial matters while allowing the couple to remain legally married.

Leave a Comment